Focusing on the judicial reasoning, identify the key problems that faced the court in this case and thereafter summarise and analyse the conclusions presented byeach judge, noting the authorities to which the judges referred and indicating whether you are able to identify a clear ratio decidendi.

Three judges (Lord President Carloway, Lord Menzies and Lord Brodie) heard the case of Docherty’s Executors vSecretary of State for Business, Innovation and Skills[2018] CSIH 57, a reclaiming motion (appeal) to the Inner House of the Court of Session.
Focusing on the judicial reasoning, identify the key problems that faced the court in this case and thereafter summarise and analyse the conclusions presented byeach judge, noting the authorities to which the judges referred and indicating whether you are able to identify a clear ratio decidendi.